Rental ban divides Escondido protesters; Crowds erupt in shouting match after vote

By: PAUL EAKINS and EDWARD SIFUENTES - Staff Writers | Wednesday, October 18, 2006 11:18 PM PDT

Christie J. Czajkowski protests outside Escondido City Hall on Wednesday.
Waldo Nilo
Order a copy of this photo
Visit our Photo Gallery

ESCONDIDO -- Marking the division of a community, a shouting match erupted Wednesday night outside of Escondido City Hall after the City Council approved an ordinance barring landlords from renting to illegal immigrants.

What started as a crowd of about 30 people before the meeting then grew into two raucous crowds totaling about 100 people. One was predominantly Latino, carrying religious symbols and picket signs. The other was predominantly white, carrying American flags and photos of officers the group said were killed by illegal immigrants.

A line of about 15 law enforcement officers kept the two sides apart in front of City Hall.

Both crowds were largely peaceful as a row of speakers lectured council members on behalf of and against the ordinance during the meeting. Members of both crowds watched the meeting broadcast on two TV monitors outside.

After the council voted, 3-2, in favor of the rental ban, a loud cheer broke out among the group in favor of the ordinance, including members of anti-illegal immigrant groups the San Diego Minutemen and Predatory Aliens Stop Killing Our Police! On the other side, representatives of civil and immigrant rights groups led their crowd in pro-immigrant chants.

Then, the two sides turned their attention to one another.

One man mocked the pro-ordinance group with a Nazi salute. The other side responded with angry shouts.

"It's not about race, right?" asked Gregorio Mercado, 30, a resident of the Los Arboles neighborhood in Escondido. "Look at that side and look at this side."

About 40 people supporting the ordinance, including members of the San Diego Minutemen, an anti-illegal immigration group, cheered what they said was a victory for the United States.

"It's over, go home," and "Pack your bags," they shouted at the anti-ordinance crowd, which included many children, on the opposite side of the police barriers.

Members of Predatory Aliens Stop Killing Our Police! waved pictures of law enforcement officers from across the country that they said had been killed by illegal immigrants.

"USA won," Saul Lisauskas, of Encinitas, a member of the Minutemen, said about the council's decision. "We are going to take this country back city by city, as long as it takes."

He said he immigrated legally from Lithuania and that other immigrants should follow the rules, too.

Elvira Jimenez, 40, an Escondido resident, said she did not come to the country legally, but worked hard to provide a home for her family as a housekeeper. The new ordinance could put her on the street, she said.

"I'm saddened because the truth is, they (the pro-ordinance protesters) are not going to do the work that we do," Jimenez said.

Representatives of civil and human rights groups criticized the ordinance as divisive and discriminatory. Those who supported the ordinance said illegal immigrants were dividing the community by not speaking English and not assimilating into U.S. culture.

Kevin Keenan, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union of San Diego and Imperial Counties, said the ACLU and other organizations would file a suit soon.

"We expect that there will be lawsuits. We intend to sue," Keenan said.

At least 40 law enforcement officers from across the county were visible at the scene, keeping the crowds separated. After the anti-illegal immigration group moved to the corner in front of City Hall at Broadway and Valley Parkway, the opposing crowd moved with them as they continued yelling at each other, separated only by a yellow police line until officers moved in to block the two groups.

The shouting match continued for about an hour after the council vote, until the crowds began to disperse at organizers' urging.

The scene was less boisterous than that of two weeks ago, when the council heard the first reading of the ordinance and eventually voted 3-2 to advance the measure. At that Oct. 4 meeting, the council chamber was filled to capacity and more than 400 demonstrators stood for hours in front of City Hall, chanting, shouting and waving signs.

Before Wednesday's meeting, members of Predatory Aliens Stop Killing Our Police! held a vigil carrying signs bearing the photos of slain officers and wearing paper hearts with photos of Marie Waldron, Sam Abed or Ed Gallo, the three council members who have supported the ordinance. Mayor Lori Holt-Pfeiler and Councilman Ron Newman voted against the ordinance.

The vigil also honored Amy Marie Kortlang, a 22-year-old Ramona resident who was killed Oct. 9 in a head-on collision on Highway 67. Rafael Ramirez Perez, 22, who had been deported to Mexico in March, faces six criminal charges, including murder and driving under the influence, and could receive life in prison.

Gary Walker, an Escondido resident and the group's founder, described the ordinance as "the first salvo to deal with the raging epidemic of the illegal immigration invasion."

-- Staff writer Sarah Wilkins contributed to this report. Contact staff writer Edward Sifuentes at (760) 740-3511 or esifuentes@nctimes.com. Contact staff writer Paul Eakins at (760) 740-5420 or peakins@nctimes.com.

205 comment(s)[-]Go to Top

Gary in Murrieta wrote on Oct 18, 2006 10:07 PM:Just the shear number of stories, and angry comments, on the NCT Web Pages about Illegal Aliens, should be a sign to everyone that Americans are fed up with Illegal Immigration.

gimmeabreak wrote on Oct 18, 2006 10:13 PM:Can we bill Waldron, Abed and Gallo for the legal fees that will be wasted defending this exercise in futility? It is Unconstitutional on a number of levels, and whether the SD Apartment Association or the ACLU files the suit, they're gonna win. The city will lose and enrich some outside law firm well into the six, if not the seven figures. There's an old saying that you cannot legislate morality. There's a more apropos version of that tonight: you shouldn't legislate out of frustration. The folks in the community who don't pay attention to how our Government works are yammering for action without realizing that they've done the legislative equivalent of applying a neck tourniquet for a nosebleed. A Federal problem demands and requires a Federal solution. And a law that appears neutral but will by necessity be applied in a way that disproportionately affects one racial/ethnic group over others is and has been unconstitutional in this Nation since the 1880's.

Low turn out wrote on Oct 18, 2006 10:20 PM:It was a low turn out because the supporters of the ban knew it was a slam dunk and All the illegals moved out last week, they too knew it was a slam dunk. They don't have far to go......... National City hope you have room for 30,000 more illegals in your Sanctuary city. Later In-sane-za!

Cal_Patriot wrote on Oct 18, 2006 10:47 PM:God Bless the Escondido City Council for taking sorely-needed leadership in helping to turn this invasion's tide. Thank you, members of the SD Minutemen, for always staying on point, no matter the opposition's scorn and name-calling rubbish. May the Lord's grace and mercy be upon the family of Amy Marie Kortlang whose young life was needlessly cut short in the name of open borders.

Priceless Wisdom From Marie wrote on Oct 18, 2006 11:23 PM:Not enforcing the laws is a political decision and has no basis or support in the law!

Adios amigos wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:03 AM:Time to go. You put up a good fight. Now its time to acccept the fact that we don't wnat you here illegally trashing up our once fine city, once fine country. Get yourselves legal, act like you appreciate our generosity. Maybe people would feel sympathetic to your plight. Until you do, get out of here. Tell your troubles to Vicente Fox.

Mission Park Study Published on Web wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:12 AM:The Mission Park study was placed on the web today. The conditions in the Mission Park area are striking! 'With an average federal poverty rate of 29%, the Mission Park area has been identified as having one of the most rapidly growing poverty rates in the State of California.' page 14. 'Renters who are new immigrants and/or are exceeding the unit capacity are also less likely to complain or identify maintenance problems that could lead to unhealthy housing (mold, mildew, poor ventilation, lead, roach or rodent infestations, or other potential health hazards).' page 18. 'A large majority (85%) of survey participants were born outside of the United States. Most participants (81%) were born in Mexico, while fewer were born in other non-U.S. areas (Central America: 3%, Other: 1%).' page 30

Cynthia wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:15 AM:This country had gone down the toilet with all the racial remarks!

John wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:16 AM:We all filled up at Sam Abed's gas station and had a beer in celebration tonight. This was LONG over due. What part of Illegal is hard to understand? It's really simple, this is America. You are welcome but do it legally and speak english. Just like Europe. What's next protesting traffic laws?

EthnicStudent wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:21 AM:Now I know who I will not be voting for this election: Mayor Lori Holt-Pfeiler and Councilman Ron Newman. Anyone who lives in Escondido and knows what it was like a few years back understands why this is so important. Symbolically, it shows we are fed up with the law breaking and that something needs to be done! Unfortuntely, given the liberal leanings of the justice system here, it will go to the U.S. Supreme Court before we see justice served.

Ambulance Chasers! wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:24 AM:noun. Slang 1. A lawyer or lawyer's agent who obtains clients by persuading accident victims to sue for damages. 2. A lawyer avid for clients. The ACLU and La Raza Lawyers Association sees gold at the end of the ilegall alien rental ban rainbow. Problem is, its fool's gold! These lingering ambulance chasers will go elsewhere as soon as they hear more sirens.

Escowatchdog wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:27 AM:Too bad the city council brought bad fame to Escondido. The ... trio must go. You don't represent me! Those minutmen are nothing but instigators that come from outside of Escondido to cause drama. Waste of our taxpayer money to have to have police guarding the city hall because of these extremists.

Oh..one more thing.. wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:27 AM:Let's definetely bill the trio for the legal mess they have gotten us into.

Awesome wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:41 AM:It's about time somebody stood against those that want everything for nothing. Problem is they are running to surrounding cities like O'side, Vista & San Marcos. Renting out homes and having 6 - 10 peple live there and run their landscaping business out of that residence. It's about time American citizens realize what they have done by letting these illegals take over this state.

City of Escondido website wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:36 AM:As soon as the city of Escondido puts up a website asking for donations for their legal defense fund against the ACLU, El Grupo, or other like minded traitors of our country that will probably file suit in the next couple of days, I'll put a $100.00 into it, and continue to give more. It would make national news and I suspect the outpouring of generosity from citizens accross our nation would flood the city's coffers as they go to battle in court to get the semantics correct to construct a legally "bulletproof" ordinance. Then the ordinance can be repeated in cities and counties around the country. This is not just Escondido's fight, it's the nation's. Escondido is one of the first in the country to take the first swing. I'm proud of Marie Waldron and the sensible city council members that supported this ordinance. This is just the beginning. Let's make this fight as costly and tiresome as possible for these groups and show these pro-illegal scoundrels the resolve of the American people with our dollars well spent. To those that think it's racist, it's only race based if only certain ethnicity's have to show proof. If everybody has to show proof it's fair to all. Yes, this is just the beginning of a better southern California and a stronger, unified country. Now, let's crack down on employers, with the ultimate goal of self deportation

WAZTHERE wrote on Oct 19, 2006 2:28 AM:Americans are fed up w/the illegal alien invasion from Mexico and all the destruction and carnage associated w/it. Americans spoke loud and clear in Escondido as they said, no more to the gross, barrio/ghetto conditions due to massive overcrowding by illegal aliens. Enough of this insanity! Enforce our laws!

quinnie wrote on Oct 19, 2006 2:44 AM:accept that the law has passed but do not accept the law. freedom will always supercede what is called "legal". sometimes we must pass on our inalienable right to "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness" to those who may not, by country and perceived national birthright, to be "equal". WHAT PART OF LIBERTY DO YOU NOT UNDERSTAND????? "security" and "freedom" is our right to challenge the status quo, our right to dissent of law and government.

John wrote on Oct 19, 2006 5:20 AM:One must wonder why the "American" Civil Liberty Union would file a lawsuit to represent people who are not Americans.

Dave wrote on Oct 19, 2006 5:45 AM:Should all American citizens get together and pool their money to drag into court and counter sue the ACLU for interfering with the rights of the American citizen?

Ron wrote on Oct 19, 2006 5:59 AM:Hey gimmeabreak; I agree with what you are saying about them losing in the courts, but I disagree with you on that you cannot legislate morality. We do it all the time, i.e. dead beat Dad's, prostitution, etc. I just don't know why this council chose to go down the ordinance path, instead of enforcing health and housing codes within their jurisdiction. Either way they would have been called racist, but that's the nature of the beast, right?

And Civil War Comes To Escondido wrote on Oct 19, 2006 6:22 AM:Congratulations on dividing your community. These are sad days indeed.

save america wrote on Oct 19, 2006 6:26 AM:Landlords who do business with persons violating federal laws are they themselves lawbreakers. Landlords are only being asked to do what is right and abide by the law. Their petty greed is getting in the way of them doing what is right, and making sure that their renter is a legal resident. High praise for the city council. We americans want our standards of living back, and we want america back. Citizens run this country, not you illegals.

Mike the Marine wrote on Oct 19, 2006 6:34 AM:Once again, the first sentience of this article shows the bias of the reporters, i.e. "Marking the division of a community". Doesn't the NCT have any professional level reporters that can provide facts without the racist spin of La Raza?

long time resident wrote on Oct 19, 2006 6:37 AM:How ignorant can the three council members be? Do they really think the rental ban will accomplish their agenda? Now how are they going to manage all the homeless illegal aliens living in the parks, streets canyons?

TCM wrote on Oct 19, 2006 6:53 AM:it does not matter what type of work you do. If you are here illegally, you should be deported immediately. Being Hispanic is not an exception to our nation's immigration laws. My taxes and the taxes of my fellow citizens and legal residents should not be supporting illegal aliens (from any country)-period. Go home, learn our language, and immigrate to our country legally.

ILLEGALS Go Home wrote on Oct 19, 2006 7:00 AM:To Mexico that is. We don't want you here.

Becky wrote on Oct 19, 2006 7:22 AM:To 'gimmeabreak' - Can we the taxpayers bill Pres. Bush for further encourageing illegal immigration by calling the MinuteMen "vigilantes"???

Jean wrote on Oct 19, 2006 7:23 AM:Thank you, City Council! Behind you 100%...

The Rental Ban Spreads wrote on Oct 19, 2006 7:34 AM:In northwest Carpentersville, Illinois, village trustees are proposing to fine businesses or landlords who employ or rent to illegal immigrants. Two village trustees said the influx of illegals are draining the village's resources. Trustee Judy Sigwalt moved into a home that once had 17 people living inside, and she said the evidence of overcrowding are apparent throughout the house.

Ridgerunner wrote on Oct 19, 2006 7:34 AM:Hmmm... Let's see. An illegal alien is a criminal. There are still laws regarding harboring criminals, aren't there? Isn't the Escondido City Council just formalizing laws already on the books? The criminal population doesn't qualify as a "racial/ethnic group" the last time I looked. According to the Miranda decision, criminals do have the right to remain silent. That is a right that I seriously wish they would exercise and stop wasting our time and our money. My vote is for full application and enforcement of existing laws and for implementing measures to stop the revolving door of exportation and illegal re-entry. The international issues are a matter for the Department of State. Do we consider this flood of illegals as refugees or invaders? All the pro-illegal rhetoric tends to define them as "refugees", doesn't it? So Federal Agencies, what do you think?

Mac wrote on Oct 19, 2006 7:35 AM:I am very happy this has taken place. When someone says illegals are doing jobs "we won't do" well let me see..yes I worked in a fast food place as a teenager, I also swung a hammer for 7 years and then went to college becoming a profesional. How about giving US born teenagers a chance at the jobs you have stolen. We will take them back and be just fine. Go home!

Ed wrote on Oct 19, 2006 7:35 AM:Maybe the ACLU should change their name to MCLU or IACLU? Then they could go to Mexico with all the illegals and help protect their rights there so that they won't need to break the law here anymore... How about it? MCLU???

Mac wrote on Oct 19, 2006 7:38 AM:I am very happy this has taken place. When someone says illegals are doing jobs "we won't do" well let me see..yes I worked in a fast food place as a teenager, I also swung a hammer for 7 years and then went to college becoming a profesional. How about giving US born teenagers a chance at the jobs you have stolen. We will take them back and be just fine.

Help America Vote Act wrote on Oct 19, 2006 7:40 AM:This Federal law was passed in 2002 and phased in over several years. Section 303 [42 USC 15483] requires voter registration applicants to either provide a valid driver's license number, or, for applicants who do not have a valid driver's license number, the last four digits of his/her Social Security number. Good thing Arnold has repeatedly vetoed efforts to give driver licenses to illegal aliens!

Pretty Extreme wrote on Oct 19, 2006 7:47 AM:Gary Walker wants to stop the "raging epidemic of the illegal immigation invasion". Pretty extreme language. Well, I think we should stop the raging epidemic of ignorant and immoral people. What about stopping the billions of dollars in retirement/pension benefits for public employees? What about stopping the lenient sentences for child molesters? What about stopping the corruption at the federal level of government? What about stopping the war in Iraq? No. Gary has bigger fish to fry - he has to stop the "illegal immigration invasion", because if you live in a poor neighborhood, live with extended family, are low-income and if your last name is Latino - well then you must be an illegal and a criminal. Gary Walker and the word Extremist are synonymous!

response to gimme... wrote on Oct 19, 2006 7:49 AM:The second poster on this blog is just plain wrong. The ACLU will not win this lawsuit. Escondido has a great legal team, and they wouldn't have said it was defendable if it wasn't. All this will do is delay the law some. Furthermore, it won't cost much at all. Escondido does not plan on hiring outside help, so all the expense really is is legal filing fees. Escondido Attorneys get paid the same whether they're working on this case or working on others. You're a joke. This ordinance is the right thing to do. Illegal is illegal, plain and simple. This ordinance isn't just about Mexicans. It addresses anybody that's here illegally. The first group to cry racism is the first group out of ideas.

To gimmeabreak wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:07 AM:Since when does The Constitution of the United States apply to foreign citizens? Maybe the ACLU should file a suit against the U.S. government because the sanctions against North Korea are unconstitutional? Absurd? yes, because the U.S. Constitution applies to it's citizen on U.S. soil, not illegal aliens or other governments. Can you say, ILLEGAL?

We always do the work wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:08 AM:I don't understand how these illegal immigrants have come to the conclusion that we (citizens and legal resident aliens) "...won't do the work [they] do" (quote from Elvira Jimenez in the article). HELLO! I am a US citizen, and I live in a working class neighborhood where it's the same story every Saturday: Moms and daughters clean their own homes & do laundry, Dads and sons mow & edge their own lawns. Moms look after their own children, no nannies here. The kids wash the family cars. Some of us still give our kids chores, ya know. Maybe the rich ladies might have to break a nail now, or their husbands might have to give up a round of golf, boo hoo. But we average, working-class American families are already doing that infamous "work nobody else will do" ourselves. We always have.

Robert wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:10 AM:Go home and come back legally or dont come back at all!! .. This invasion must end here and now! Let the ACLU and liberals sue, why would we expect anything different from them. Hell they dont even want voter ID.. do we see a pattern here? Lets keep drawing lines in the sand .. we owe it to our children!

Arthur wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:10 AM:Leave the immigrants alone we have all been immigrants and if not our ancestors have been immigrants. They should be aloud to be here and get there citzenship. California was once mexico so let them come to our free country.

NeverForgetAmy wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:11 AM:My heart goes out to the Kortlang family. Rafael Perez had been arrested 4 times on DUI, and finally deported to Mexico in March. Of course, he was right back in this country a few months later, driving drunk, resulting in the death of a precious young woman. If this was an isolated incident, we could all grieve for Amy and then forget about this incident. But it's happening all over the country. Many police officers and innocent drivers have lost their lives to illegal aliens who have no business being on our highways. We need a border fence, we need troops on the border to counter the Mexican drug cartel militias, we need rental bans, and we need to recall or impeach our public servants who refuse to enforce our existing immigration laws.

mariana wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:11 AM: my respect and regards to the parents of amy marie kortlang,its saddens me to hear some ones child was taken becase of whats been happening for years between mexico and U.S. AND ITSHOULDNT HAVE TO GO THAT FAR.BUT IF YOU WERE TO DRIVE DOWN THE FENCE THAT SEPERATES US AND MEXICO ON THE SIDE IF MEXICO YOU HAVE PICTURES AND CROSSES ALL ALONG THE FENCE OF PEOPLE THAT HAVE BEEN KILLED. AND IF YOU THINK ABOUT IT FOR SOME RESON U.S HAS ALLWAYS THOUGHT THEY HAVE THE RIGHT TO TAKE WHATS NOT THERES LIKE WITH INDIANS THAT WHERE BETRADE IN BELIVEING THEY WOULD BE FREE AND INSTEAD THEY WHERE KILLED THEY TRUSTED US AND GOT KILLED INSTEAD.THERE HAS BEEN SO MUCH CORRUPTION COMING FROM US AND YOURE WORRIED ABOUT RENTING TO ILLEGALS.YOU SHOULD BE SO GRATEFUL NOTHING WORST HAS HAPPENED TO YOU.COUNT YOURE BLESSINGS FOR MANY THINGS.FROM NOT AFRAID TO SAY IT. GOD BLESS YOU AND ME OF COURSE

Oh No wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:16 AM:What to do, a crowd of 100, CALL OUT THE MARINES!!!!

NLRC Revealed As Mecha Front wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:18 AM:A big black eye to CSU San Marcos for coming to the meeting to claim misuse of its research. A reader of the Mission Park report (now available online) can only conclude that illegal immigration is a key factor causing growing poverty in the Mission Park area. The research and report was performed and written by the National Latino Research Center which was founded during the administration of past CSUSM President Alexander Gonzalez. Alexander Gonzalez proudly points to his membership in the Movimiento Estudiantil Chicano de Aztlan (MEChA), a national organization for Chicano/a students. We have now come to the understand that MeChA is a racist organization that spreads a hatred of the 'gringo' invaders of Aztlan. Thus, a rational observation is that the NLRC at CSUSM is a platform for latino political hacks to spew out biased research under the guise of sound research using the respectability of the CSU system as cover. The blatant politcal act last night by the CSUSM representative just confirms the lack of academic integrity that still infects the CSUSM campus. What a disgrace!

Tom wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:19 AM:I hope the ACLU and the activist at least have the heart to tell these illegals that maybe just in case, they should be looking elsewhere to rent. I can see it now the law is enforced and hundreds of illegals that had been promised that the law wouldn't be enforced, out in the streets. You activist and ACLU should be ashamed of yourselves!!

Just get out wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:22 AM:I am glad to see that this passed.Thank you to all who supported this. Now if the rest of SD would get a hint we could be rid of illegal immigrants once and for all!!

Wisdom also wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:40 AM:This is treason what our government is doing to us!! This is a Federal issue and the illegals should be deported as according to AMERICAN LAW!

JR wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:42 AM:Thank God. The powers that be - ethnocentric interest groups, the agricultural industry, the chambers of commerce - are desperate to override the will of the people. They want to pit American middle class workers against third world immigrants who will work for slave wages. It is immoral and disgusting. I have no sympathy for any business that bases its success on continuing to exploit people at the expense of the American middle class. Tough luck. That's what happens when you base your business model on slave labor.

Mars wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:49 AM:Let's keep this process going from city to city!

maria wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:51 AM:OK! let's get rid of all the illegal immigrants and then see who is going to do the field work, housecleaning, washing dishes in the restaurants. These are jobs we the US citizens are refusing to do because we are too good for 6.75 and hour. See if you can get the impoverished teens to go out and work instead of selling and doing dope. See if you can get the lazy welfare recipient to go out and work in the fields instead of sitting at home eating bon bons. See if you can get anyone other that the illegals to take your crap. And while you accuse the illegals of crimes, remember, the black, white, asian and other US citizens are just as guilty of crimes, but since they are "US citizens" who cares, right? Bull, just remember, your ancestors were here illegally, this land belonged to the native americans. Shall we send you back too?

I would like to encourage wrote on Oct 19, 2006 8:58 AM:all of your to add the ACLU to your Christmas Card list. It will only cost us .39 and they will spend HOURS and DAYS opening up their mail in case someone might have sent money. I use to belong to the ACLU but I have learned that they only represent ILLEGAL aliens and terrorists. NOT AMERICANS

hmmm wrote on Oct 19, 2006 9:01 AM:Just a bunch of hate mongers!! Disgusting! I am ashamed to say that I live in Escondido.

ZBTETA wrote on Oct 19, 2006 9:07 AM:This is crazy. Why should we provide food (food-stamps), housing (HUD) and money (welfare) to illegals? They broke the law getting here, and EVERY effort should be made to eject the ones here and prevent more from coming. Children of illegals should not be US citizens, only children of people legally here. If the nuts of ACLU want to waste time in the courts, then we citizens should sue them for infringing on our rights. They clog the courts, waste tax-payer money, and generally polute the environment with their stinking hides. Let all the nuts who support the illegals pay for them out of their pockets alone, and stay out of the pockets of honest working Americans.

Legal Citizen wrote on Oct 19, 2006 9:12 AM:Its all good. Its ALL good. My brothers and sisters are more than willing to lend a hand to our illegal relatives that are renting by using our info so they can stay put. There are so many ways around this, its funny. They arent going anywhere. Just one more challenge out of many. Its not a big deal to them. So everyone who thinks this is a victory somehow, we'll just let you keep thinking that.

Hey Gimme a Break wrote on Oct 19, 2006 9:12 AM:The constitution protects the citizens of the United States. If you are a person that is here illegally, guess what....you are not a citizen. It's about time that illegals, regardless of race or crede, take the hint and leave the country then pursue the legal avenues that are available to return if they so desire. And when/if they do return they need to assimilate into society rather than stay a sepparate entity. Am I saying that they need to give up their roots? No. I tell you what though, this whole "African American", "Asian American", "Latino American", "XXXXX American" thing is dividing this country. If you want to be an American then be just that, An American. Don't look for or expect preferential treatment based on race, ethnicity or country of origin.

Former Resident wrote on Oct 19, 2006 9:16 AM:I believe I saw a sign that equalled the US to Nazi Germany? It's rather hilarious, not to mention completely stupid, to tear down the country you are mooching off of. Don't like it? LEAVE!!!!!!!! PLEASE LEAVE!!!!!!!! Illegals are NOT welcome here. Come back after you have done it the right way. I'm sure those apartment buildings on Fig St. will continue to be available for you all to stuff fifteen people into.

John, vista wrote on Oct 19, 2006 9:21 AM:yes I am glad all the illegals will be gone I hope they do not invade the rest of the north county. It's time we take our country back and make it nice to live here, not afraid to live here..

Haha wrote on Oct 19, 2006 9:24 AM:Damn Escondido is going to be a ghost town. I can't wait to hire a white housekeeper. If one exist. Yeah, illegal immigrants take all the good jobs. Just living the dream. I think i'm going down to the 76car wash today and have my car washed by all the white guys there. They just take all the great jobs. You guys are a joke. You don't want any of those jobs, so just stop pretending your doing this for your country. You guys havent done anything special, so quit trying to act like super heros.

Concerned to Gimmeabreak wrote on Oct 19, 2006 9:26 AM:Stick to facts. The problem is illegal immigrints, a great majority of whom are of one racial/ethnic group. Back in the day they would have said this was calling a spade a spade. But, of course, that would now be a very biggoted, racial statement.

In Perspective wrote on Oct 19, 2006 9:34 AM:Compared to the $11,000,000 per hour and the 2800 American lives lost in the Iraq debacle, illegal immigration is a non-issue. But at least the Minutemen have something to show for their racist weekend-warrior antics.

Free At Last wrote on Oct 19, 2006 9:35 AM:To quote a great American "One small step for man.." Escondido City Council I thank you for youe wisdom and courage, and pray that San Marcos, Escondido, Vista and other area cities follow suit. And to all the protestors I say you are welcome here, just follow the rules for entry. To those here by commision of a crime, why di I want criminals to be my fellow cirtizens? Thanks

Escondidian wrote on Oct 19, 2006 9:36 AM:To gimmeabreak. Excellent. I guess all Mexicans need to get a yellow star. We can revert back to banning these people from everything U.S. Instead of solving this issue we are using outdaed methods to solve this very serious issue.

A great day for the USA wrote on Oct 19, 2006 9:40 AM:Finally a law that makes sense.

So Sad wrote on Oct 19, 2006 9:43 AM:So Sad; I'm have a feeling that something ugly is going to happen, just remember that theres someone more powerfull than any congress men in the US(Bush Toys) my prayers are with you so called "Americans" God Bless You on your future pain

Pedro wrote on Oct 19, 2006 9:51 AM:Ask any Border Patrol Agent about stopping drugs and illegal immigration, it ain't gonna happen with what they have now..As long as there's a demand for for cheap labor and drugs, the supply will flow, just like prostitution.

Les wrote on Oct 19, 2006 10:09 AM:Interesting how all of the opponents to this new law could not be bothered to, or were unable to comment in English for the news cameras. Doesn’t that just help to make the point of how necessary this law is? If assimilation were not such a problem, this would not be such an important, volatile issue. Thank you Escondido Counsel. Oceanside Counsel, time to step up to the plate!

A Resident wrote on Oct 19, 2006 10:11 AM:I spoke to someone last night about this. Their concern is who in the city council and or law enforcement is going to over see this? If a slum lord doesn't comply. How will the city know? Does the city have a plan to check all rental units? I doubt it. How about all the people who rent room in their homes. I'm for getting rid of the trouble makers. They should though have a measure in place to get the good ones legal. Keep in mind that if they become a US citizen. They loose all rights in their home land. That means owning property etc. What would you do?

What's next wrote on Oct 19, 2006 10:16 AM:Cattle cars pulled by locomotives to transport anyone of Latino descent to concentration camps? You won't be satisfied until it comes to that, now will you?!

dirtysubie wrote on Oct 19, 2006 10:30 AM:everybody that is againest this policy is ranting and raving about how un-constitutional this new ordinance is. Makes my blood boil, in order to have rights in this country, you have to be a LEGAL citizen. What part of illegal do these people not understand ? It makes the immigrants who come here and work hard at becoming a legal citizen look bad and harder on them

somebody who cares wrote on Oct 19, 2006 10:33 AM:Thank God for ESCONDIDO FINALLY realizing that something needs to happen...maybe us "LEGAL FOLKS" will start to get some rights around here and not have to pay for everything the illegals think they are owed!! For Example...WELFARE

Webster's says.. wrote on Oct 19, 2006 10:45 AM:il?le?gal? [i-lee-guhl] Pronunciation: –adjective. 1) forbidden by law or statute. 2) contrary to or forbidden by official rules, regulations, etc. Additionally, llegal alien: 1) a foreigner who has entered or resides in a country unlawfully or without the country's authorization. 2) a foreigner who enters the U.S. without an entry or immigrant visa, esp. a person who crosses the border by avoiding inspection or who overstays the period of time allowed as a visitor, tourist, or businessperson.

To gimmeabreak: wrote on Oct 19, 2006 10:52 AM:Regarding the question on who will pay to defend against self-serving lawsuits by ACLU, etc....sometimes this is the price that we all pay to make a stand for what is right. By the overwhelming ordinance-supporting comments we are seeing regarding this issue....I believe the people have spoken and we want law and order BACK! We don't want to become another Mexico. GO ESCONDIDO!!!

To Gimmeabreak wrote on Oct 19, 2006 10:54 AM:I have no doubt that you are right on all counts, but tell us, what are we to do when the federal response to the federal problem is not forthcoming? Our federal representatives offer nothing beyond doublespeak and wordplay, and show disregard for the wishes of their constituents, the citizens who are crying out for help with the illegal immigration problem. What are we supposed to do, just sit back and take it?

Pay the price wrote on Oct 19, 2006 10:56 AM:In a time that we spend bilions of dollars for the defence of rapists and murderers. Allow our health care and social services to be abused to the point of bankrupcy. I will gladly aprove the spending of any moneys to protect the rights of legal citizens in Escondido. In fact we should have a collection to see just how bad Americans want the illegals gone! I pray more cities follow the bold and courageous actions of Escondido.

On a happy note wrote on Oct 19, 2006 11:02 AM:to landlords, once the illegals are gone, Escondido is going to become where everyone will want to rent. With our class rooms returning to normal, no waiting at the hospital and no more hit and runs, Escondido will become very popular in California!

Hey Cal_Patriot wrote on Oct 19, 2006 11:06 AM:if you want to bring God into this, what about a sense of MERCY??? Do you even know what "the Lord's grace" means??? I'll give you a hint: racism has nothing to do with it!

jeff wrote on Oct 19, 2006 11:21 AM:Gimmeabreak says “the ordinance is unconstitutional on a number of levels” but only specifies one: “a law that appears neutral but will by necessity be applied in a way that disproportionately affects one racial/ethnic group over others is and has been unconstitutional in this Nation since the 1880's." This “disproportionate impact” theory doesn’t make laws unconstitutional if they have a legitimate governmental purpose that can’t be done in other way. Any immigration law will have a disproportionate impact if there is a racial/ethnic group that is dominant among those who violate the law but of course those laws aren’t unconstitutional. I too would like a federal solution but in the absence of the feds willingness to enforce existing laws, local governments have taken to using those same federal laws to craft local ordinances. That’s what this ordinance does. I don’t think it will be effective given its design. The federal jurisdiction over immigration will be raised but this law doesn’t run counter the existing federal laws on the books. Ironically it’s the laws pushed by opponents of this ordinance such as “sanctuary cities,” that is being sanctuaries from federal law.

Danny's Conspiracy Theory wrote on Oct 19, 2006 11:22 AM:Danny Perez has a conspiracy theory. The rich Sam Abed is going to empty Mission Park of tenants, collapsing property values. Then the rich Sam Abed is going to snatch up those properties at bargain basement prices and get rich. It seems that Danny does not understand competition in the market place. First, if property values are low, it is because legal residents find them undesireable as a residence. Anyone purchasing such properties would need to invest sizable capital to rehabilitate the properties, something the present owners must be unwilling to do. Also, other investors will be bidding on such distressed properties, so the rich Sam will not be able to buy up everything at below market prices. Danny's vision is the kind that locks latin american cultures in poverty. Envy of people who get 'rich' by taking financial risks and working hard to improve a community. I hope many people get rich by 'conspiring' to change Mission Park from an area with one of the fast growing poverty rates in California, to an area that rivals the new Downtown San Diego as a desireable place to live.

TO Cal Patriot wrote on Oct 19, 2006 11:23 AM:How can u use the Lord's blessing on people like that?? Doesn't the bible teach u to love one another?? u are obviously not doing it because in God's eye we are all equal. MAY GOD BLESS YOU AND HAVE MERCY ON YOU.

Becky wrote on Oct 19, 2006 11:29 AM:Hmm... this is the 2nd or 3rd time my respectful entries haven't been posted. Wonder if I should stop our NCT paper subscription. Oh, and stop placing my ads, too.

Enough religion! wrote on Oct 19, 2006 11:39 AM:God gave us the earth, but he didn't create rules for driver's licenses, immigration, etc. That was our doing for our protection. Now follow the rules!

quinnie wrote on Oct 19, 2006 11:50 AM:EVERYONE GETS REPORTED!!! lets drive escondido into bankruptcy and stall this stupid act with red tape. be prepared to show YOUR proof of citizenship proud american. I'm going to go spit on the statue of liberty in your honor

Ron wrote on Oct 19, 2006 11:52 AM:How do you think Jesus would feel about the slum lords "tuna-canning" these illegals in small apartments? And about the city council not enforcing the health, safety, and housing codes for those illegals protection? And what would he say about all these later comers, i.e. El Grupo, La Raza, MALDEF, etc. only coming now because they can get their names in the papers. Where were these people when these illegals are living in squalor? Were they asking this council to enforce the housing codes, protecting these illegals? Or were they doing nothing?

To those opposing CalPatriot wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:20 PM:To those upset at "CalPatriot" or others using Christ/Christs' love as an EXCUSE for allowing illegals to stay - LOVING someone doesn't mean ignoring their improper behavior and standing by them even though they break the law. Instead LOVING someone is encouraging them to do the RIGHT THING. While Christ walked w/ the sinners - He also encouraged them to stop sinning (i.e. - He led by example why it's important to stop breaking the law). So, for those using the Bible or "GRACE" in this instance - you most certainly don't understand God's version of Grace. You are doing what Jude verse 4b warns against ... "These are godless men who change the grace of our God into a license of immorality." Careful ...

A Resident wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:21 PM:Has anyone driven around and made a list of some of the property's that should be cleaned up. Please get out in the next few day's and drive through the city. Make a list, take pictures, etc. Then present them to City Hall. I'm doing just that this weekend. I want to see just how serious the people in city hall are. We will see how long it takes to clean up little MEXICO. Or we will see that this is just a political issue. Anyone serious as I am?

Dave in Oceanside wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:45 PM:Even though I live in Oceanside, if Escondido needs donations for their legal defense fund against the ACLU I will also give $100.

Boom, boom music? wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:46 PM:I won't miss it! Seriously, If people wanted you gone and you didn't legally belong there, wouldn't you just leave? I keep hearing about all of this skin tone based pride, Mexican pride and all of this other gibberish, but if you were really proud would you stay where the overwelming majority wants you gone? I believe they have pride and selfishness confused with each other. Either way, I won't miss them or their overwelming "right to entitlement" twisted logic. Adios

It's Time wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:48 PM:It's time to bring back Prop. 187! I'm more than willing to pay the $10 a gallon for orange juice or lettuce to save the more than $9 billion a year it costs California to support these illegal immigrants. Just think how much more I'll have in my paycheck! I was in the hospital without insurance and paid $35,000 out of my pocket. The girl in the bed next to me was illegal and receiving treatment for cancer and walked away without paying anything. She also had medi-cal pay for her 2 children born here illegally. What's up with that. They are receving financial aid the same as California residents in our colleges and university. This is totally bogus; it's time to change it.

Hispanic and Proud wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:57 PM:It is scary to know there is so much HATRED in this city. Does anyone understand racial profiling? Are all landloards going to ask every tenant to prove citizenship? What if they were from Canada or Africa? This is only going to promote bad things. Yet you all love Mexican food and will have Mexicans clean your houses or yards.

INTERACIAL wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:58 PM:WHY STOP THERE, WHY NOT KILL ALL MEXICANS, AFTER ALL HATE AND RACISM IS WHAT MADE THIS COUNTRY GREAT. WHAT'S NEXT PUT ALL THE MEXICANS( BY THE WAY THIS IGNORANT RACISTS ARE IGNORING THE FACT THAT INDOCUMENTED PEOPLE COME FROM ALL OVER THE GLOBE,ASIA, EUROPE, MIDDLE EAST NOT JUST MEXICO) THIS SEEM TO BE DIRECTED TO MEXICANS, IS NAZI GERMANY ALL OVER. SO SAD, BUT THE FACT IS THAT HISPANIC HAVE MORE CHILDREN THAT WHITHE PEOPLE AND IN A COUPLE OF YEARS, HISPANICS WILL BE THE MAJORITY AND THANKS TO THE INTERACIAL COUPLES, YOU MIDDLE WHITE NAZIS WILL BE A THINGS OF THE PAST. RACIAL HATE WILL NOT PREVAIL. SINCE YOU CANNOT DISCRIMINATE AFRICAN AMERICAN ,YOU ARE RE-INDIRECTING YOUR HATE TO AN EASY TARGET. WELL, JUST THINK, WE ARE MORE THAN YOU AND OUR GENES ARE STRONGER THAN YOURS, THE ARE MORE INTERACIAL COUPLES THAN EVER AND YOU MIDDLE AGE NAZIS ARE GOING TO END UP IN A NURSING HOME. WE WILL OUTNUMBER YOU :)

Concerned wrote on Oct 19, 2006 12:59 PM:Kevin Keenan of the ACLU is suing the City? I forget, who exactly does the ACLU represent? What does the A stand for? Sorry, I'm getting confused.

Belt & Suspenders wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:01 PM:If the Feds want to block this ordinance, then we should just use what little help they will give us for a more effect enforcement scheme. Federal immigration law (8 USC 1621) already in effect declares that a illegal alien is not 'is not eligible for any State or local public benefit.' It allows the local government to check the immigration status of each benefit recipient. I propose giving each rental dwelling unit a mandatory $1 housing assistance benefit each month. On the back of the $1 benefit check would be eligibility certification language that the tenant would need to agree to to receive the benefit and cash the check. Each tenant that fails to cash the check would need to provide the City with the documents needed for citizenship or lawful residency verification. Those documents could be verified using the SAVE program set up to allow such status checking. Also, the City would audit the cashed checks from time to time to monitor for fraud in the benefit program.

To A Resident wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:09 PM:Mexico changed its laws about 8 years ago to allow dual citizenship. Many American immigrants who have become American Citizens are dual citizens with dual allegiances. They retain their loyalty to their home country. Many latinos activists will get up in a meeting an openly claim US citizenship, but will remain silent about their other citizenship.

L.C. wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:10 PM:City after city, we American citizens will take back our country!!! Awesome job Escondido! This is a great triumph for us taxpayers who continue to fork out millions of dollars supporting illegals. The sorrounding cities need to do the same & we voters should not accept any less from council members or other officials who are running in the November election. I would be willing to donate money (as many Americans would) to any fund that supports enforcing immigration laws & deporting illegals OUT OF OUR COUNTRY.

Greg wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:10 PM:Your staff writer EDWARD SIFUENTES has consistently written his articles with a clear bias towards illegal aliens and their cause. Why can't he report as an unbiased reporter instead of cater to the whims of the illegal aliens who are coming here in droves? Is he a supporter of illegal immigration and in favor of giving them 'rights' that only legal citizens should enjoy? Come on EDWARD SIFUENTES quit the bias and report like you are supposed to and give us the objective truth. Escondido did what hopefully other cities, particularly those in north San Diego need to do, and pass legislation that sends a message. The message is 'no mas' to the influx of illegal aliens who have turned large portions of Escondido into a barrio. It's not about race. It's about quality of life. It's about putting a stop to all the problems illegal aliens bring with them, such as high crime, high teen-age pregnancy rates, lower scholastic achievement, the drain on our social welfare system, and the degradation of our neighborhoods. As a resident of one of the cities in North County, I just hope this doesn't turn into a migration to my city. It takes acts of courage to do what the Escondido city council did, and hopefully make illegal immigration less attractive to those trying to 'jump to the head of the line' like illegal aliens continue to do.

Dave in Oceanside wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:10 PM:Marie Waldron, Sam Abed or Ed Gallo, get the Escondido web site up for donations fighting the ACLU and watch the cash roll in.

morty wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:12 PM:GOOD MORNING WHAT A PREETY DAY IN THE NEIBOR HOOD.AND NOW ITS TIME TO STOP BEING HATEFUL.WE CAN GO OUT AND GET OUR OLD JOBS BACK AND BE HAPPY.TO BE A CITIZIN IS A GOOOD FEELING.AND SO IT IS.

To Concerned wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:22 PM:ACLU is the Alien Criminal Liberation Union.

I feel sorry wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:30 PM:for San Marcos, Vista, Oceanside hope you guys can get your City to do something before you get our problems.

This is great!! wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:35 PM:They went from waving the Mexican flag in defiance, to holding up crucifixes and calling us racists. Whats next, riding a unicycle backwards while juggling pesos? Can you guys please stage another big rally, I'm still waiting to see the bearded lady. Please don't bring the zebra painted donkey out again, it's humiliating to the donkey. The fact is, there is no logical argument to allow them to stay and overcrowd and burden our finite resources.

Concerned former citizen wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:36 PM:As I read, it said Illegal citizens not Mexicans! So maybe the ACLU and Danny Perez should stop trying to stir up trouble and let's get back to the issue at hand of Illegal's coming here and abusing our systems. Yes it is our governments fault also, because there are so many laws on the books now that if they enforced them this would never have been an issue.

Prediction wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:40 PM:My crystal ball says that nearly all illegal females that can reproduce will be dropping anchor within the next year

Patriot wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:47 PM:Agree with previous posting re getting a web site going for donations. A few calls to some talk show hosts and donations will come in from all over the country. Escondido is taking a risk going up against the ACLU. The American people know this and plenty of us are willing to share in the risk in order to see Escondido succeed. It's worth money to prevent: 1) another son or daughter from being killed by a drunk illegal alien driver, 2) another emergency room from closing, 3) another bond issue to build more schools, 4) another honest business folding because of competitors' illegal labor, 5) another American college kid losing financial aid to an illegal alien, 6...n) another...

Mary wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:50 PM:To posters who type in CAPS. I get that you are shouting but it makes reading your postings very difficult. When we read we actually read the shape of words formed by the combination of letters. When you type in CAPS, all the words are the same shape and makes the reader have to read each indivdual letter. You communicate better using small letters and using leading capitalization for leading letters of proper nouns such as names, places, etc.

Concerned wrote on Oct 19, 2006 1:51 PM:Another award for making our point: INTERACIAL. "BY THE WAY THIS IGNORANT RACISTS ARE IGNORING THE FACT THAT INDOCUMENTED PEOPLE COME FROM ALL OVER THE GLOBE,ASIA, EUROPE..." And, extra credit for all caps. Nice touch! Another great example of our education dollars at work. Go ESL! No child left behind.

Peter wrote on Oct 19, 2006 2:02 PM:Who cares about this stupid law that can never be enforced? All you happy people will get nothing from this law.

Jeff wrote on Oct 19, 2006 2:15 PM:Mike is right about the value of votes being eroded through great disparities in the number of voters between districts. You can go to the Secretary of State’s registration statistics at http://www.ss.ca.gov/elections/elections_u.htm to see this for yourself. Download the excel file, organize the districts by number of voters and then check to see which party control which districts. Why does the media never report this? The rationales used in the very same court rulings that led to the requirement that districts be equal in population can be used to argue that illegal immigration has made that standard the wrong one to use. It’s Orwellian to argue that all votes are equal when some votes are clearly more equal than others. By the way, Speaker Fabian Nunez’ district is the undisputed champion of the lowest number of voters

tracy wrote on Oct 19, 2006 2:17 PM:I am so happy for Escondido. We left the area because of what has happened. Unfortunately, it followed us and my new neighborhood is the same way as the old one. Hopefully, more cities will pass similar laws. I,too, thought you had to be a citizen for the ACLU to care. Maybe they need to worry about those of us who actually belong here first.

A Resident wrote on Oct 19, 2006 2:18 PM:Subject: Maxine says Yep! I passed it on... I am sorry but after hearing they want to sing the National Anthem in Spanish - enough is enough. No where did they sing it in Italian, Japanese, Polish, Irish (Celtic), German, Portuguese, Greek, French, or any other language because of immigration. It was written by Francis Scott Key and should be sung word for word the way it was written. The news broadcasts even gave the translation -- not even close. Sorry if this offends anyone but this is MY COUNTRY - IF IT IS YOUR COUNTRY SPEAK UP ---- please pass this along~ I am not against immigration -- just come through like everyone else. Get a sponsor; have a place to lay your head; have a job; pay your taxes, live by the rules AND LEARN THE LANGUAGE as all other immigrants have in the past -- and GOD BLESS AMERICA! PART OF THE PROBLEM Think about this: If you don't want to forward this for fear of offending someone-----YOU'RE PART OF THE PROBLEM !!!! Will we still be the Country of choice and still be America if we continue to make the changes forced on us by the people from other countries that came to live in America because it is the Country of Choice?????? Think about it! IMMIGRANTS, NOT AMERICANS, MUST ADAPT. It is Time for America to Speak up If you agree -- pass this along; if you don't agree -- delete it

Permanent Tourists wrote on Oct 19, 2006 2:30 PM:when you decided to squat on our land and steal a piece of Mexico, we came with it. So get over it! We'll stay right here thank you very much, because we've been nestled in here and were quite cozy long before white people even thought to come out here. CALIFORNIA isn't an english word!

RENTERS WANTED ~ wrote on Oct 19, 2006 2:47 PM:Renters wanted in San Marcos, Vista. Oceanside and all over SD county. If you still want to live in Escondido, you can always ask you USA born cousin ss. Problem solved.

One for the Good guys wrote on Oct 19, 2006 2:50 PM:I hope the Poway city council is paying attention becuause this needs to be passed here ASAP. How about it Mayor Cafagna? Will you take a stand and protect the city before its too late, or are you just going to sit in your north Poway home and not notice the blight that is accross the street from Wal Mart? No more illegals ruining our city and schools!

One problem wrote on Oct 19, 2006 3:11 PM:with using your USA born cousins social security, it is that he has to live at the residence. I don't think your USA cousin is going to want to share your apartment with his American family.

Jeffrey wrote on Oct 19, 2006 3:14 PM:I do not understand the statements by illegal immigrant advocates concerning "working hard although here illegaly". Where in the law does it say that as long as I work hard I do not have to follow the law? May I park next to a fire hydrant as long as I work hard? To Permanent Tourist: California belonged to the native peoples, then Spain, then Mexico than the USA (by treatie). The squatters as you call them are the last three listed- including Mexicans. Do you propose that England belongs to the Celts becuase the Normans, Saxons, and Danes came over and took the land? The argement is rediculous. The American people set their own laws and Mexico has no vote, the American people have set a law that provides for a manner in which immigration may happen and may not happen. By the way, what does Mexico do to Guatamalians who come into Mexico illegaly- It deports them.

ruffrcr wrote on Oct 19, 2006 3:23 PM:Mexico stole California from Spain who stole it from the Indians - the Mexicans need to get over it...California is the West Coast border of AMerica now...

Roberto wrote on Oct 19, 2006 3:42 PM:I wonder if being illegal and living in Escondido will now carry a significant status? Cause you can't stop a freight train with hate.

To Mariana wrote on Oct 19, 2006 3:43 PM:When you said, "THERE HAS BEEN SO MUCH CORRUPTION COMING FROM US..." are you talking about corruption from the American citizens??? You've got to be kidding! Think for a minute - Why are the illegal aliens jumping over the border fence in droves every day??? It's because the government of Mexico is so corrupt!!! If there are crosses on the Mexican side of the border remembering those who died it is because they CHOSE to cross illegally. We didn't force them. We can't be responsible for that! We are not responsible for the illegal aliens and we shouldn't support them! THEY ALONE should be responsible for their own choices, illegal or not, and face the consequences. Period.

Jack wrote on Oct 19, 2006 3:45 PM:I guess the grasses will go brown, the laugry will go undone, the houses will go dirty, the children will have to go to daycare, no more Mexican taco shops, no more Cinco de Mayo parties no more fresh fruit or flowers. All the jobs the "upper class" considers to be to good to do but "a Mexican will do it", but not anymore. I would love to see a white or even a black person out there picking fruit all day long in the hot summer days, what a sight to see, I can't wait!!!

To Hispanic and Proud wrote on Oct 19, 2006 3:46 PM:I think your suggestion is a good one. How hard is it to ask every tenant to prove citizenship? That's what us employers are asked to do when we hire someone? If everyone is asked to do this, then it isn't profiling, right??? I hope all landlords will follow your suggestion!

To One problem- wrote on Oct 19, 2006 3:52 PM:Are you going to go make sure the cousins does not live there? mmm maybe the anchor babies socials are the solution. haha see there is another option! and there are many more!!

About time wrote on Oct 19, 2006 3:53 PM:time to go home illegals! Improve your country now. When's this going statewide/countrywide?

Broken Taco wrote on Oct 19, 2006 4:01 PM:Mexico hates its illegals. Interesting how double-sided they are. Viva USA!!

giveMEabreak wrote on Oct 19, 2006 4:01 PM:I fully endorse legal immigration to this country. My grandfather came here in that manner at the turn of the last century. Benefits to illegal aliens, in any form, whether they be medical (other than emergency/critical care), social, or HOUSING are simply not appropriate, defensible, or FAIR. Thousands stand in line every year to legally come to this country. Why should we accept (and pay for) those who have jumped in line, shunned the vetting process, and in many cases become a social burden? Don't think we can fill the jobs? I say we can! I picked strawberries as a teen in New York for much needed spending money. I washed dishes. I mowed grass. They were INTERMEDIATE jobs. Never intended as a lifelong source of income for most. If legal residents use them as such, then more power to them, but stop feeding Americans this nonsense that we can't continue on as a country economically without illegal immigrant labor. What a load of ...! Legal Immigration- SI! Illegal Immigration- NON! ...

Hello? wrote on Oct 19, 2006 4:05 PM:"I have no doubt that you are right on all counts, but tell us, what are we to do when the federal response to the federal problem is not forthcoming? Our federal representatives offer nothing beyond doublespeak and wordplay, and show disregard for the wishes of their constituents, the citizens who are crying out for help with the illegal immigration problem. What are we supposed to do, just sit back and take it?" YOU ARE SUPPOSED TO VOTE THE CRUMBS OUT OF OFFICE INSTEAD OF TAKING THE LAW INTO YOUR OWN LOCAL HANDS! QUIT VOTING PARTY LINES AND START EDUCATING YOURSELVES!

In other News : wrote on Oct 19, 2006 4:09 PM:An El Paso judge this afternoon handed down sentences of 11 and 12 years in federal prison for border agents Compean and Ramos who were convicted of shooting a Mexican drug mule.

Maggie wrote on Oct 19, 2006 4:11 PM:To A Resident complained about dual citizenship. Get Over It! If not another Mexican came into the country, the anglo majority will no longer exist in much less than 18 years. All this hateful stuff about citizens, legal and illegal will all be moot. The hatred and division that is being created now by oppurtunistic demagogue politicians (think Waldron) will come back to bite ya!

I report wrote on Oct 19, 2006 4:12 PM:ALL suspious crimes, it is not up to me to determine if a crime has actually been committed, my only responsibiltiy as a citizen of the United States of America is to report anything suspious to the proper authorities. This includes suspected illegal immigration violations.

Gary in Murrieta wrote on Oct 19, 2006 4:15 PM:Mr. Sam Abed is being interviewed on the 640 KFI Am Radio right now. Go to their webpage for "live stream"

Tend your garden wrote on Oct 19, 2006 4:16 PM:Where is ABED from? He doesn't look like "my people" and he has a funny name! Why doesn't he go back to where ever he came from? Notice, hate doesn't stay where you put it--it keeps growing and spreading. What kind of name is Gallo? I never know what to think about names that end in vowels, they are suspect. Is he connected to the Mafia? At least Waldron, sounds English, but is she pure or is she part Irish?

To Hello? wrote on